By Jenell Johnson
American Lobotomy experiences a large choice of representations of lobotomy to supply a rhetorical heritage of 1 of the main notorious strategies within the historical past of medication. the improvement of lobotomy in 1935 was once heralded as a “miracle therapy” that may empty the nation’s perennially blighted asylums. despite the fact that, simply 20 years later, lobotomists in the beginning praised for his or her “therapeutic braveness” have been condemned for his or her barbarity, a picture that has in basic terms soured in next a long time. Johnson employs formerly deserted texts like technological know-how fiction, horror movie, political polemics, and conspiracy concept to teach how lobotomy’s entanglement with social and political narratives contributed to a robust picture of the operation that persists to at the present time. The e-book provocatively demanding situations the background of drugs, arguing that rhetorical background is important to figuring out scientific heritage. It deals a case examine of the way medication accumulates which means because it circulates in public tradition and argues for the necessity to comprehend biomedicine as a culturally positioned perform.
Read or Download American Lobotomy: A Rhetorical History PDF
Similar specific demographics books
Puerto Ricans have an extended heritage of migrating to and development groups in quite a few components of the us looking for a greater existence. From their arrival in Hawai'i in 1900 to the post-World battle II era—during which groups flourished through the Midwest and New England—the Puerto Rican diaspora has been transforming into progressively.
Authored by way of the editor of the major go back and forth journal for individuals with disabilities, rising Horizons, this moment version of Barrier loose go back and forth remains to be the definitive advisor to obtainable commute in the event you use a wheelchair, walker, or cane or have any actual disorder that can decelerate their gait.
Essays specialize in Baroque as an idea and class of study which has been primary to an realizing of Hispanic cultures over the last numerous hundred years
"Interesting and fresh-represents a major and full of life problem to a self-discipline that in the meanwhile is caught in its personal units and desires an intensive critique to start to maneuver forward. "--Paul McHugh, Johns Hopkins collage tuition of Medicine"Remarkable in its breadth-an fascinating and useful contribution to the burgeoning literature of the philosophy of psychiatry.
Additional resources for American Lobotomy: A Rhetorical History
I knew that” (Dully and Fleming 2007, 231). Although the information in previous case-file entries was taken from interviews Freeman had conducted with his father and stepmother, the information about the attack was from a meeting his father had not attended. Rodney Dully later confirmed that his wife’s charge had been fabricated (247). During an interview, Howard and producer David Isay encouraged Rodney to explain why he had given his consent for the operation. Yet he would say only that Lou, who had never liked Howard, had insisted it be done.
In closing, with a nod to Donna Haraway (1988), who champions the value of “partial perspective,” I want to acknowledge the limits of this book’s vision. This is not a disclaimer, but a point of order. I do not aim to write a universal history of psychosurgery. What this book offers is a situated account of lobotomy as it intersected with American culture at different points in its history. Although this is clearly an ethnocentric approach, it is necessarily so. Lobotomy has a different rhetorical history in the United States than it does in the United Kingdom, Norway, Brazil, or Japan.
Returning to 1936, the moment when lobotomy first entered the pages of newspapers and magazines, chapter 2 traces the shifting claims about the operation’s therapeutic value in medical journalism by examining how patient case histories were used as evidence of lobotomy’s social value. As arguments began to shift from the praise of lobotomy to its condemnation in the late 1940s and early 1950s, two related shifts also took place: the subjects of case histories used to support arguments about lobotomy overwhelmingly switched gender from women to men, and the interpretation of the operation’s effects shifted from positive to negative.
American Lobotomy: A Rhetorical History by Jenell Johnson